Created by Mike & Mollie. If you enjoy our work, please subscribe here.
We all like to think we’re managing our money well, but sometimes the beliefs we hold about frugality are actually working against us. It’s easy to assume that buying the cheapest option or cutting every possible expense is the best way to save, but I’ve learned the hard way that this isn’t always true. For years, I thought I was being smart by hunting down every sale and refusing to spend money on anything “unnecessary,” only to realize later that some of those habits were actually costing me more in the long run. Whether it was cheap products that fell apart too quickly, bulk purchases that went to waste, or skipping small maintenance tasks that led to bigger expenses, my so-called “frugal” choices weren’t always the smartest ones.
The truth is, frugality isn’t about spending the least amount of money possible—it’s about spending wisely. Some of the most common frugal habits can actually lead to wasted time, lost money, and even financial stress if you’re not careful. I’ve had to unlearn a lot of these myths myself, and I want to help you avoid the same mistakes. Let’s go through some of the biggest frugal living myths that might be secretly draining your wallet.
1. Buying the cheapest option always saves you money
It sounds logical—spend less, save more. But in reality, the cheapest option often costs you more over time. Whether it’s bargain-bin shoes that fall apart in a few months, a budget appliance that needs constant repairs, or cheap furniture that doesn’t survive a move, poorly made products can end up costing you more than their higher-quality counterparts. Instead of automatically reaching for the lowest price tag, consider the long-term value. A well-made item might have a higher upfront cost, but if it lasts years longer, you’re actually saving money in the long run.
2. DIY is always the cheaper option
We love a good DIY project, but not everything is worth the effort. Some do-it-yourself attempts require specialized tools, expensive materials, or a level of skill that you don’t have—leading to costly mistakes. What seems like a money-saving project can quickly become a time-consuming hassle that ends up costing more than hiring a professional. Before tackling a DIY job, factor in the true cost, including your time, the potential for mistakes, and whether you’ll use the tools again. Sometimes, paying a pro is actually the frugal choice.
3. Couponing and extreme deals are the key to saving big
Coupons can be great—when they’re for things you actually need. But extreme couponing can turn into an expensive habit if you start buying things just because they’re on sale. A $5 item you didn’t need is still $5 wasted, even if you got a “great deal.” Plus, many coupons are for name-brand products that might still cost more than their generic counterparts. Instead of chasing every discount, focus on mindful spending—plan your purchases, stick to a list, and compare prices to make sure you’re truly saving money.
4. A bigger bulk purchase always means bigger savings
Warehouse stores and bulk deals can be money-savers, but only if you actually use what you buy. Too many people fall into the trap of stocking up on bulk items that go bad before they can be used, whether it’s food that expires, beauty products that dry out, or cleaning supplies that take up valuable storage space. Bulk shopping only makes sense for items with a long shelf life or things you regularly use. Otherwise, your “savings” turn into waste, and you end up throwing money (and products) away.
5. Making everything from scratch is always more economical
Cooking at home is usually cheaper than dining out, but making everything from scratch isn’t always the best move financially. If a homemade recipe requires a long list of expensive ingredients you’ll never use again, or if it takes you hours to prepare something that you could buy for just a few dollars more, it’s not really a frugal choice. Some homemade items, like bread or pasta, can be fun to make but don’t always result in major savings. The key is balance—cook simple, cost-effective meals but don’t be afraid to use shortcuts when they save you time and money.
6. Avoiding all credit cards is the best way to save money
Credit cards aren’t the enemy—poor spending habits are. Many people avoid credit cards out of fear of debt, but when used wisely, they can actually help you save money. Cashback rewards, travel perks, and fraud protection are all benefits that cash and debit cards can’t offer. Plus, responsible credit use helps build your credit score, which can lead to lower interest rates on major purchases like homes and cars. The key is to use credit cards strategically—pay off your balance in full each month, and treat them as a tool, not an excuse to overspend.
7. Paying cash for everything helps you control spending
Using cash for all purchases might seem like a great way to stay on budget, but it has its downsides. You miss out on credit card rewards, lose the ability to track expenses automatically, and risk carrying large amounts of cash that could be lost or stolen. While cash can help some people stick to a budget, others find that using a budgeting app or tracking spending through a credit or debit card is far more effective. The key is not how you pay, but how you manage your spending. If cash helps you stay on track, great—but if digital tracking keeps you accountable, don’t be afraid to use it.
8. You should always do free activities instead of paid ones
There’s nothing wrong with enjoying free activities, but automatically rejecting paid experiences to “save money” can be a mistake. Sometimes, spending a little money on a class, a hobby, or a well-planned trip can bring far more long-term value than constantly choosing the free option. Investing in experiences that enrich your life, build skills, or bring joy can be a wise financial decision. The key is to budget for them wisely—frugality isn’t about spending nothing, it’s about spending intentionally.
9. Skipping maintenance and repairs saves money
One of the worst ways to “save” money is by putting off maintenance. Whether it’s skipping oil changes for your car, ignoring small leaks in your home, or waiting until the last second to replace worn-out shoes, neglecting upkeep can lead to major repair bills. A $50 tune-up today is much cheaper than a $2,000 engine repair down the road. Preventative maintenance is one of the smartest investments you can make—taking care of your belongings now can save you from expensive replacements later.
10. You should never spend money on convenience
Many frugal-minded people refuse to spend money on anything that makes life easier, believing it’s always wasteful. But sometimes, paying for convenience can actually be the smarter financial choice. If a small expense saves you hours of valuable time, prevents burnout, or helps you stick to a healthier lifestyle, it might be worth it. Things like grocery delivery, a meal subscription, or a housecleaning service can be worth the cost if they improve your quality of life and free you up for more productive activities. Frugality isn’t about making life harder—it’s about optimizing your spending so you can enjoy both financial security and a well-balanced life.
By rethinking these frugal living myths, you can shift your focus from just “spending less” to making smart financial choices that actually save you money in the long run.
